I'm in need of a set of 4 tires for my 2011 wrx. It still has the original summer tires. I've been meaning to replace them with all seasons and now I have to after picking up a nail right on the edge of tread and sidewall. Can't repair it and its forming a small bubble. I haven't even driven my car for almost 2 months. Opting for the always fashionable and definitely gay vw beetle convertible or my forester when the mrs lets me.

Equally I'm not sure which tire to get so recommendations would be helpful.

Size is 235/45R17

Looks like I can buy online, save on sales tax but pay more just to ship. I miss the days of a $30 tyre and a $100 tyre was high falootin! The pearls of getting old.

Any advice? Shop recommendations?